This is the same company that put out The Powerpuff Girls.
...the f**k happened?
Now that we’ve reach Beta is Dead’s Fourth Anniversary I think it’s time for a rant. Now normally I would write a comic book rant, probably something about Stephanie Brown or something like that, but instead I think I’ll talk about cartoons. And gender. There’s been a pretty big controversy going around the internet since late November that I’ve been aching to comment on but just haven’t had the time. Well the time is now. If you are unfamiliar with who Paul Dini is (shame on you, by the way) he is the co-creator along with Bruce Timm, of Batman: The Animated Series which is still today considered by a great many people to be the best cartoon ever made. Understand that Dini is a pretty big deal when it comes to children’s television. So anyway a while ago Dini appeared on film director/giant nerd Kevin Smith’s podcast “Fatman on Batman” to talk about Batman. Somewhere during the two part interview Smith goes on a rant about how much he loves the new cartoon Beware the Batman, which Dini has nothing to do with but Smith points out that when the show gets going it’s the only Batman show to match the level of depth of BM:TAS. Then Dini destroys Smith’s life by informing him that Cartoon Network had removed it from the schedule and would probably end up canceling it if it hasn’t been canceled already. And indeed the show was put on hiatus back in October and as of this writing it has yet to have a solid return date (they said January but January is almost over) and have offered up no explanation. But Dini has an idea of what the problem is. Now you can listen to the podcast yourself here (this stuff starts around 38 to 41 minutes in) but I will summarize: companies like Cartoon Network cancel or otherwise don’t renew deep, arc driven shows like Beware the Batman because they attract the wrong demographic; families and girls. But they only want certain shows to be watched by young boys. Let me repeat his: Cartoon Network has possibly self-sabotaged and canceled their shows because they attracted too large of a female audience. That is one of the most f**ked up things I’ve ever heard. More ranting, swearing, and screaming after the jump.
Okay, that’s a joke obviously. The greatest man who ever lived, as we all know, is either Charlemagne or Neil Patrick Harris.
Pictured: Proof that France is cool
Last month I caught the pilot two part episode of the new Young Justice cartoon and shared some of my initial thoughts with you.If you recall I didn't love it and one of my major problems with it was the fact that there wasn't a whole lot of female characters doing, well, anything.Miss Martian was the only female member of the principal cast to make an appearance and only then it was at the very end where she played no part in the episode’s plot.It made me unnerved that the show was basically a boys club.Well a couple of days ago I was doing…something (Likely I was on TV Tropes) and I came across Greg Weisman’s Q&A feature on a fan website.
Some background: Greg Weisman, who seems to be one of the main folk involved with Young Justice, once worked on a cartoon called Gargoyles. And it was awesome. Like, basket full of candy and stuffed pandas level of awesome. It kind of assumes the audience has a working knowledge of Shakespeare, but aside from that it was great. For two seasons everything was okay but by Season Three Disney, the men behind the show, apparently wanted to retool some things and Weisman ended up leaving the series after only one episode which resulted in the remainder of the show’s run being something of a train wreck. Fans now like to pretend that last season never happened. Weisman agrees and in the wake of his departure he tended to tell anyone who would listen or ask how the show would have gone had he remained onboard in amazingly nerdy details. A very involved fan base eventually formed on the internet and in short order a blog was set up where he answered various questions about the show and has been doing it the past eleven years (He also wrote continuation comic). This is something only a few creators do with their fans and those who do are BELOVED for it (See Also: Joss Whedon, Kevin Smith).
Elisa: Remember that time our evil clones turned to stone forever?
Goliath: No, and neither should you!
Anywho like I said I happened to come across the site that hosts the Q&A and noticed that someone recently posted the very concern I had about Young Justice (No girls, and whatnot) and was given a very detailed answer by Greg.
You can find the piece here, but if it’s somehow moved try searching for it on the site using the date it was answered (12/21/10). If you don’t feel like reading all the text on that site the basic gist is this: the way the episode was structured they couldn’t justify the cash to spend on voice actors to read a few superfluous lines, so characters like Wonder Woman and Black Canary ended up having to sit in the background twiddling their thumbs since, script-wise and story progression-wise, they didn’t have anything to add (Red Tornado and tons of other males do the same thing for the same reason). As for Miss Martian it seems they were worried about having to introduce and characterize five characters over the course of the two episodes and at the end of the day it’s just easier to concentrate on a smaller cast (Of course Not-Superboy was pretty hard to watch and I’m not certain that ended up being time well spent). The reasoning behind not replacing one of the three principal characters (Robin, BlAqualad or, bleh, Kid Flash) was that those characters along with Speedy are the four traditional teen sidekicks and that they didn’t want to leave any of them out, which is of course the mindset only an old comic nerd would have (As opposed to young comic nerds like me who believe Wally West and Kyle Rayner are the real Flash and Green Lantern, God help us) and he admits to that himself.
So does this reasoning appease me? Well yes and no. I certainly understand where he’s coming from. As fans we have to understand that the magical world of entertainment is fraught with compromises. No show will ever achieve the level of perfection that we, or the creators, truly want and it’s really just best if we enjoy what we have rather than bitch about what we don’t. That’s all good on paper, of course, not so great in practice but hey, we can try at least. So yeah, I understand that they did what they felt they needed to get something they thought would be good out. On the other hand I still wish they had written an episode that included more women and there’s little that can change that opinion. Weisman promises that the next episode and the series in general will not have that problem and I’m willing to give it a chance. I’m not the type of asshole that condemns a show after only watching one episode, after all.
Well, usually I'm not
The point I really want to make is that I am enamored with Weisman for being so accessible to his fans.In addition to ten years worth of answering questions I think it’s awesome that he would listen to the concerns of his fans about his new show and calmly and thoroughly explain his position even if I myself don’t necessarily like what he had say.Hell the site wasn't even about Young Justice and he’d probably be in the right for just ignoring it.That’s what they call “class”, folks.Let’s all thank Mr. Weisman by watching Young Justice every week when it officially debuts January 7th 2011 on Cartoon Network.
Check out the fan site where Ask Greg is featured here.
This was pretty much just an hour them repeating that they aren't sidekicks
In case you were wondering I’m thoroughly enjoying Avengers: Earth’s Mightiest Heroes.It’s a good chunk into its first season and I can honestly say it’s one of the most entertaining Marvel cartoons I’ve ever seen…so far.I’ll be doing a season review once it wraps up though when that will be I have no idea.Fair’s fair though, so I figured I’d watch the premier of Young Justice and post some initial thoughts like I did with EMH last month.As I understand it this was the first two episodes, “Independence Day” parts 1 and 2.Obviously it’s hard not to draw comparisons to the Avengers cartoon but there’s an important difference between the two shows: technically EMH’s season premier was the sixth episode of the series where this one was the first.Character development as well as exploration of the world had already begun with EMH where in this cartoon everything starts here at once.As a result things felt more jumbled here.Anyway here’s some thoughts and notes I took while watching it.
-My sister says that Robin was stealing lines form 10 Things I Hate About You
-Speedy is a jerk.I hope we never see him again
-I like how the characters have distinct personalities, but where are the ladies?
-Zatara?Really?What is this, 1941?
-Dear DC Comics: Kid Flash is a horrible name.Please stop using it.Love, Beta
-Robin needs to lay off the jokes...for all our sakes
-BlAqulad’s powers sometimes seem a bit too much like Green Lantern.I guess that’s okay, there’s no “Teen Lantern” after all, but even so I think I’d prefer a power ring over “vague water powers”
-I should point this out while I’m thinking about it: the animation is great!It’s a more realistic style than the Avengers.I dig it a lot
-Robin calls Kid Flash “KF”?That’s not clunky and awkward at all
-Holy crap, Superboy is nothing like his comic book counterpart.Not even close
-Superboy is not only different he’s annoying.He’s like a teenage Wolverine with half-ass Superman powers
-This show is the opposite of Teen Titans cartoon in terms of structure,style, and tone.The lesson: be careful what you wish for
-I am not enthusiastic with the character design for Blockbuster
-Two Green Lanterns on the Justice League?Why?
-Hell yeah Captain Marvel!
-Seriously, go to hell Not-Suberboy.You’re awful
-Jesus Tap-dancing Christ on a Sofa, these main characters really seem to enjoy displaying how “rebellious” they are
-Red Tornado being here is so far the only thing that feels familiar to the original comic
-Let’s send teenagers on covert opts missions.I foresee no problems with this
-Why the hell was Miss Martian only introduced in the last two minutes of the episode?Why wasn’t there any female character along with the four guys running around on the adventure?Why do none of the female Justice League characters have any lines?I know a lot of character didn’t get lines but still this seemed like a Boy’s Club to me
Okay so after watching the premier episode I’m not particularly impressed.The animation is good and the dialogue is mostly without major problems (But minor glitches made me roll my eyes several times) and most importantly doesn’t feel like its talking down to its audience.However the characters are not very compelling and seem sort of flat.Robin is annoying with his Mary Sue-like ability with hacking (Which seems more like a Tim Drake thing rather than a Dick Grayson trait), BlAqualad doesn’t seem to actually have a personality and Not-Superboy is a rage fuel asshole that bares almost no resemblance to his comic book counterpart.The writers need to flesh out the cast big time but truthfullyJustice League/Unlimited had a very similar problem with its season premier and that show ended up being fantastic so there’s no need to condemn anyone yet.However shame on the writers for apparently forgetting to add women to this episode.I can forgive the fact that despite seeing no less than three female members of the Justice League on screen none had any speaking lines but why did they decide they didn’t need Miss Martian to take part in the first adventure?With her traditional power set she would have been more useful than BlAqualad was. Or did we need more time flesh out Not-Superboy’s psychotic rage issues and thus couldn’t be bothered with a fifth member at this time?In any event there are some unfortunate implications there.
Bottom line is that this show didn’t exactly floor me with excitement.There are some pretty cool things about this show, and BlAqualad wasn’t the annoying problem I was worried he might be, but at the end of the day I was more bored than interested while watching the pilot, which was the opposite reaction I had with EMH.When the series starts proper in January I hope the kinks are worked out.Also the writers couldn’t have picked a worse personality to give to Not-Superboy.I’m sure he’ll be pissing me off all season long.The Avengers cartoon is officially winning the war.
Two are retired, two are renamed and one stopped wearing a bad wig
So I’ve had time to do research on this “Young Justice” cartoon and I’m pleased to announce that my somewhat downer statement from the Avengers: Earth Mightiest Heroes blog from earlier this month was a bit un-called for.Young Justice will probably be really good as it places a massive amount of DC Comics lore in the capable hands of Greg Weisman also created both The Spectacular Spider-Man and Gargoyles, two shows I’d rank very high on a “Top Cartoons of All Time” list. Plus news from the New York Comic-Con has put my mind somewhat as ease.The most important thing to take in mind with this new show is that it’s not necessarily a horrible adaptation of a underappreciated comic book because, well, it apparently has almost nothing to do with the book it shares a name with.There’s no point in being angry about it then.
Anyway I’d like to discuss the cartoon but before I do that I think I’ll talk a bit about the original comic for the uninformed.
In 1998 DC apparently realized that at that particular moment they had a surplus of teenage heroes/sidekicks running around in their titles, a lot of them with their own series that were doing well.The obvious next step would be take some of these characters and put them on a team and try them out in their own book. Apparently they were hesitant to start yet another Teen Titans reboot so instead they tried something a little different.And so Young Justice: The Secret #1 introduced a team-up involving the third Robin (Tim Drake), Impulse (Bart Allen, currently know…ugh, “Kid Flash”) and the modern version of Superboy.The three were featured in another “pilot” book titled Young Justice: World Without Grown-Ups and soon thereafter they were rewarded with an ongoing series.The trio was later joined by three other heroes: newcomer Secret, the new version of Arrowette and the second or third (Depending on which continuity DC currently says is the proper timeline) Wonder Girl (aka Cassie Sandsmark).Todd DeZago and Todd Nuack created the team (Nuack also drew them pretty much the entire book’s run) but the book and the team is mostly associated with comic writer extraordinaire Peter David who wrote damn near the entire series.
Robin, Impulse and Superboy unaware that its the gritty 90s
Note the lack of guns and pouches
The book was known for being on the silly side of things and being more about having fun than teen angst and the fact is that a lot of fans enjoyed that style.I myself was drawn to the book because I was familiar with Superboy and Impulse (Due to the Superman: The Return of Superman and Impulse: Reckless Youth trade paperbacks) and was regularly reading Robin’s solo title at the time and seeing the three teaming up intrigued me.To this day I have a strong love of Tim and Bart, even if some of the changes to Bart over the years have been questionable, and a certain fondness for Secret.In fact I think we are way overdue for a return of Secret who has been out of the hero biz for the last six or seven years.Anyway the book was eventually canceled with the miniseries Titans/Young Justice: Graduation Day which led into yet another reboot of the Teen Titans (By my count the fifth or sixth time) which most of the remaining team ended up joining.That book was darker and a bit more angst filled than its predecessor but also involved characterization that some say were in contradiction to how Peter David (And other writers) had written them previously.Still even to this day Tim (Now known as Red Robin), Superboy, Wonder Girl and…bleh, “Kid Flash” are portrayed as being a tight nit group and regularly guest-star in each other’s titles.
No wait, I meant it's "extremely" cliche at this point
Anyway new team members include Miss Martian, who’s background seems to have been changed to strengthen her connection to TheMartian Manhunter, Atermis, a character who resembles Arrowette and shares a name with a Wonder Woman supporting character but the producers are being secretive about her true identity, and of course the leader of the team AqualadBlack Aqualad, a character created just for this show.
A moment on the new Aqualad, if I may.The character was apparently conceived by the show’s creators in a dubious attempt to provide racial diversity.I won’t touch that today since I’d be here all night if I did.I assume that since there aren’t really a whole lot of viable choices for teenage black super heroes floating around in the DC library they had little choice but to just make someone up and tag an existing name on him.But then again why they chose not to include Static, Cyborg or Black Lightning’s daughters Thunder (Though I guess she isn’t really a teen) and Lightning in the show I have no idea.In fact after randomly naming off four young black DC superheroes off the top of my head that have all been relevant in some form in the last six years I’m downright baffled why they felt they needed to make an African-American version of Aqualad at all.Seriously, the world already thinks Aquaman is a joke; why the hell would they take his sidekick seriously?Because he can make water weapons?Because he has Simon Phoenix from Demolition Man’s haircut?Please.Let’s say Cyborg and Static don’t fit in with the sidekick theme the show seems to be going for.You could still have Thunder or Lightning (The latter being a better choice) and then just add Black Lightning to the Justice League (Who are regular guest stars) and BAM; a double whammy of diversity.
Sorry Static but it's back to obscurity with you
Regardless it’s Black Aqualad on this show and, like it or lump it, he will likely make history.In the devolvement stages of the show A-List comic writer and DC big wig Geoff Johns (Who wrote the Post-Young Justice version of Teen Titans that I mentioned) saw the early designs of the character, thought it looked cool, and decided to bring him to the DC universe proper.Though several comic characters were originally created in other media and later written into the comics (Including Harley Quinn from Batman: The Animated Series, Firestar from Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends and recently Chloe Sullivan from Smallville) but I believe he’ll be the first character created by a TV show that ended up debuting in the comics first; simply because the issues introducing him happened to be released prior to the show’s series premier.That’s pretty weird, man.In the comic the character is Jackson Hyde and his story is currently unfolding in the pages of Brightest Day but I heard a strange rumor pegging the show’s BlAqualad as being Cal Durham, a minor Aquaman character from the 70s.Since I can’t find official sources confirming this anywhere for now I’ll assume it’s just pure jibber jabber and Jackson is the man both in the cartoon and books, but should it ever prove to be true then that means that Black Aqualad and Mr. Hyde were NEVER the same guy and that DC and the show’s creators may lack basic communication with each other.Which would be hilarious.
Don’t get me wrong.There’s plenty of things to get excited about here.Several aspects of the show were explained after the New York Comic Con and several of them have got me all sorts of eager.For one thing the characters will age.This may not seem too important but really with a lot of serial fiction, comics included, I get pretty sick of the same status quo year after year.Development is the key to good characters after all and frankly a guy who starts the show as being 14 years old and ends it being 18 will not be the same person he started as.That said who knows if it will ever be noticeable.The show is supposedly influenced by our old pal Joss Whedon and has something of a dark tone as a result.Obviously that may or may not be a positive but after that lighthearted/manic Teen Titans cartoon from a few years ago it should be a nice change of pace.There have also been some hints that not all of the team member will survive the first season.I will believe it when I see it; the number of main characters actually killed in a kids cartoon (As opposed to knocked out, in a coma, trapped in another dimension, captured by villains or simply “missing”) is pretty dang low.Also Peter David is apparently signed on to write a few episodes and has implied that he’ll be bringing in some of the spirit of the original comic…and heavily hinted an appearance by Secret, which would be her first outside of the books.Sweet!
The most interesting thing though is that there promises to be tons of cameos and guest appearances by other characters.I LOVE seeing characters show up like that in a cartoon I’m watching.That was part of the charm of Justice League/Unlimited and is the only thing I like about Batman: The Brave and the Bold.Unlike some other shows there are no embargos preventing the writers from using any of the vast characters in the DC backlogs so just about any hero or villain you can think could be featured at some point.We know Captain Marvel will appear at some point which is enough to make me actually watch the show by itself.Also the Wonder Twins will guest star so it’s not all good news I’m afraid.
Pretty, but still super lame
Bottom line is that this show could be extremely amazing.As of now it has all the tools a show needs to be incredible.Technically I think it has more going for it than Avengers: Earth’s Mightiest Heroes has, though in EMH’s defense Disney and Marvel Comics have provided significantly less talking about awesome their show will be and more showing how awesome their show will be and are thus winning the war.Time will tell who wins in the end but if what we think we know turns out to be true the real winners will be the fans.
Wesley Snipes & His Amazing Friends
Young Justice premiers November 26th 2010 on that one channel that used to play cartoons all the timeCartoon Network. I can't wait!
If you recall months ago I wrote what I called “Avengers Week” to celebrate theSaturday Morning Cartoon Show’s Avengers: United TheyStand episode. I angrily tore that show apart in my SMCS Companion Piece. If you’re too lazy to look it up basically I was unhappy that it lacked the Big Three as regularly characters (Captain America and Iron Man showed up but Thor never did outside of the theme song) and instead focused on several lame ass C-characters like Bikini Tiger BarbieTigra, included the unwanted addition of Power Rangers-like “Super Armor” complete with ridiculous transformation sequences, and started off with an unspectacular first episode. Being that the Avengers are Marvel’s answer to the Justice League of America its hard not to draw comparisons to the fantastic cartoon series Justice League/Justice League Unlimited and sadly the premier superhero team of the Marvel Universe’s first animated adaption was absolute garbage next to it.
But the good news was that, this fall, a new cartoon that on paper looked much more true to the comic was scheduled to premier on Disney XD. Judging by the early trailers the show seems to feature the original founders including the Hulk (!) and Captain America as the primary members with the likes of Hawkeye and Black Panther joining later on. On paper that sounded really awesome. Already it has shaken off the major problems I had with the original Avengers cartoon by going back down to basics, i.e. drawing from the classic Stan Lee and Jack “The King” Kirby stories from the 60s much like how the unjustly canceled Spectacular Spider-Man (Marvel’s best animated series, in my humble opinion) was based on the classic Lee/Steve Ditko stories.
Why the hell was this so hard to get right ten years ago?
Here were are in October and the show’s series premier is a mere weeks away. In a unique twist rather than having the story begin on that night Marvel and Disney have been releasing a 20-Part prologue that acts as introductions to all the primary characters both online and on TV. As of this writing I’ve managed to catch all of them so far (Parts 1-13) and they look amazing! The episodes (Clocking in about 5-6 minutes each) follow one of the future Avengers through an introductory adventure that showcases off their personalities and abilities. So far every hero (And many villains) shown comes off like a badass. Even Incompetent ScientistSupremeHank Pym looks good and he’s a goddamn joke.
Hank Pym building a robot that will kill us all
Thor, the Hulk, Iron Man (being played very similar to his live-action movie counterpart), Nick Fury, and the others all are made to look like a big deal. The Wasp comes off pretty good too which makes me annoyed that Marvel Studios has opted to not include her in the upcoming movie, leading me to assume they’re allergic to strong females (And since self-proclaimed feminist Joss Whedon is directing that film it makes me even more annoyed).
Anyway these shorts are great. The writing it well above average, the action is great and the sheer amount of fanboy fan service in the forms of character appearances and cameos is enough to make any Marvel fan salivate. If the show proper continues this trend we may have a new contender for best comic animated adaptation in history. And since introductions are being handled in the shorts we will undoubtedly start the series out with a Bang/Wham episode that brings the characters together without a lot of padding. It’s like trying to replicate one of the main reasons Justice League was so good (Prior continuity) without having to wait four or five years to do it...you know, the opposite of what the film version is doing. In any event I cannot wait for the premier and I genuinely excited to see this show!
Now walk towards the screen in slow motion for extra awesome
DO IT NOW, DAMN YOU!!!
On the DC Comics side of things it looks like Warner Bros. will not take this lying down as next month we’ll see the premier of Young Justice, based off the comic of the same name (Which, by the way, was one of the titles that brought me back to reading comics in High School). The show is being headed up by the man who created both The Spectacular Spider-Man andGargoyles; none other than Greg Weisman. Combined with the fact that the comic featured some of my favorite characters DC ever created, Tim Drake the third Robin, Bart Allen as Impulse, and also cool (And unappreciated) newcomer Secret, I feel like this show will also deliver-
What’s that? Tim and Bart have been replaced by Dick Grayson and Wally West (As the lame sounding Kid Flash)? And Superboy is in fact the only character featured from the original comic to be included in this cartoon? And there’s a show created BlackqualadBlack Aqualad shoehorned in to insincerely create diversity while in reality just revealing how little representation of minorities exists in comic books proper? Well I believe that doesn’t sound like a show I’d want to watch at all, sir.
Possibly the worst thing ever or the best thing ever
Stay tuned to find out
Check out the Avengers: Earth’s Mightiest Heroes prologues here, but make sure you don’t accidentally watch that other Avengers cartoon that is also stored there.